They looked for answers. What they found was a secret that changed everything.
Our Father begins with a phone call — simple, almost mundane — and unravels into one of the most disturbing true-crime revelations in modern American history. This chilling Netflix documentary exposes the story of Dr. Donald Cline, a once-respected fertility specialist in Indiana, who inseminated dozens of women with his own sperm without their knowledge or consent. What unfolds is not only a violation of ethics, but a grotesque breach of bodily autonomy, family, and identity.
At the center of the film is Jacoba Ballard, a woman who takes a DNA test out of curiosity — only to discover she has a half-sibling. Then another. And another. What starts as a personal journey quickly turns into a horrifying pattern. The walls close in not just on Dr. Cline, but on an entire system that allowed his deception to go unchecked for decades. With each sibling discovered, the emotional weight deepens: identity shattered, trust eroded, families torn apart.
Our Father is more than an exposé; it’s a searing indictment of a medical and legal system ill-equipped to handle crimes cloaked in lab coats and lined with silence. The film balances procedural investigation with the raw emotional reality of those affected — children who never consented to their origins, mothers who unknowingly carried the violation within them, and communities forced to grapple with proximity and betrayal.
)
Shot with restraint but heavy with atmosphere, the documentary avoids sensationalism and instead amplifies the quiet devastation in every revelation. The horror is not in the visuals, but in the implications: how close it came to remaining hidden, how little recourse the victims have, and how many similar cases may be buried under bureaucracy.
Ultimately, Our Father is a scream against silence — a demand for truth in a world that too often protects power over people. And in its final moments, it leaves viewers haunted by the simplest, most devastating question: How many more?
